Welcome to PCForumz.com!
FAQFAQ      ProfileProfile    Private MessagesPrivate Messages   Log inLog in

Hard Drives... What is now reasonably priced but just behi..

 
   Hardware Problem Solving Community! (Home) -> Hardware General RSS
Next:  merge two hard drives using partition magic 8?  
Author Message
nada

External


Since: Jul 09, 2007
Posts: 2



(Msg. 1) Posted: Mon Jul 09, 2007 9:31 pm
Post subject: Hard Drives... What is now reasonably priced but just behind "cutting edge"?

Hey all!

I presently have 2 SATA HD's of 300 Gigs and 2 IDE HD's of 300 &
200-something Gig - and i can't tell the difference between the sppeds
of each. All are typical CompUSA/Best Buy WD Caviar or Maxtor units
and are 7200 with 4 or 8 meg buffers.

I'm gonna upgrade and spend a little extra this time. I don't want
the newest-high end (especially in price) HD's but I'd like what is
now reasonable in price and better than the advertised units in the
paper. What do I need to look for? Newegg has a WD Raptor that's
10,000 RPM 16MB Cache that's Serial ATA-150 for $200. 200 bones is
fine but it's only 150 Gigs! Yikes!!! I NEED capacity.

Any suggestions on fairly new tech and speed without getting soaked
for being the first one on your block to get the cutting edge stuff?

Thanks!!!!! And any "education" on HD's would be appreciated!

Thanks for your help!!!!

 >> Stay informed about: Hard Drives... What is now reasonably priced but just behi.. 
Back to top
Login to vote
kony

External


Since: Jan 03, 2004
Posts: 6148



(Msg. 2) Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2007 3:19 am
Post subject: Re: Hard Drives... What is now reasonably priced but just behind "cutting edge"? [Login to view extended thread Info.]

On Mon, 09 Jul 2007 21:31:43 -0700, nada.TakeThisOut@home.net wrote:

>Hey all!
>
>I presently have 2 SATA HD's of 300 Gigs and 2 IDE HD's of 300 &
>200-something Gig - and i can't tell the difference between the sppeds
>of each. All are typical CompUSA/Best Buy WD Caviar or Maxtor units
>and are 7200 with 4 or 8 meg buffers.
>
>I'm gonna upgrade and spend a little extra this time. I don't want
>the newest-high end (especially in price) HD's but I'd like what is
>now reasonable in price and better than the advertised units in the
>paper. What do I need to look for? Newegg has a WD Raptor that's
>10,000 RPM 16MB Cache that's Serial ATA-150 for $200. 200 bones is
>fine but it's only 150 Gigs! Yikes!!! I NEED capacity.
>
>Any suggestions on fairly new tech and speed without getting soaked
>for being the first one on your block to get the cutting edge stuff?

To be blunt, the answer is no. You want better performance
but that always entails spending more (if we rule out the
duds from any particular era and just focus on mainstream
performance vs a significant upgrade from that).
>
>Thanks!!!!! And any "education" on HD's would be appreciated!
>
>Thanks for your help!!!!


As always, define the budget and the required parameters
(capacity). From there, pick the most suited candidate.
FWIW, having both capacity and performance many people like
the Hitachi 1TB, though personally I'd prefer a larger # of
drives with fewer platters each, per same $$$, and some
people just think bigger is better so it's not so clear cut.
FWIW, I don't put any large drives in desktop systems
either, there's much to be said for having a RAID5 or at
least 1 across GbE and accepting some poerformance loss, as
these days DDR2 memory is dirt cheap and quite a lot can be
cached. IOW, hard drive performance is no substitute for
boatloads of main memory unless you do a lot of video
editing.

 >> Stay informed about: Hard Drives... What is now reasonably priced but just behi.. 
Back to top
Login to vote
Paul57

External


Since: Oct 09, 2004
Posts: 984



(Msg. 3) Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2007 3:31 am
Post subject: Re: Hard Drives... What is now reasonably priced but just behind [Login to view extended thread Info.]

nada.DeleteThis@home.net wrote:
> Hey all!
>
> I presently have 2 SATA HD's of 300 Gigs and 2 IDE HD's of 300 &
> 200-something Gig - and i can't tell the difference between the sppeds
> of each. All are typical CompUSA/Best Buy WD Caviar or Maxtor units
> and are 7200 with 4 or 8 meg buffers.
>
> I'm gonna upgrade and spend a little extra this time. I don't want
> the newest-high end (especially in price) HD's but I'd like what is
> now reasonable in price and better than the advertised units in the
> paper. What do I need to look for? Newegg has a WD Raptor that's
> 10,000 RPM 16MB Cache that's Serial ATA-150 for $200. 200 bones is
> fine but it's only 150 Gigs! Yikes!!! I NEED capacity.
>
> Any suggestions on fairly new tech and speed without getting soaked
> for being the first one on your block to get the cutting edge stuff?
>
> Thanks!!!!! And any "education" on HD's would be appreciated!
>
> Thanks for your help!!!!

If you put the OS, any scratch space (like a Photoshop scratch disk
or a paging file) on the small Raptor, that might speed up things
you do frequently.

At least for me, I have a lot of seldomly used files, and if they
are sitting on a second, slow and large drive, I'd be happy.

So you could use two disks to do the job, if you want to experiment
with a 10000 RPM disk for a while. You can even make a backup image
of the Raptor, onto the other big disk, in case of a problem with the
Raptor.

I used to run a computer with seven disks in it, but the noise got
to me. I generally try to run only one disk now, for better
noise and electricity usage. You could try two disks for a while,
and see if you like the split of "small and speedy" for some stuff,
and "large and slow" for archival storage (MP3/movie).

Paul
 >> Stay informed about: Hard Drives... What is now reasonably priced but just behi.. 
Back to top
Login to vote
GT

External


Since: Jul 13, 2005
Posts: 310



(Msg. 4) Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2007 6:01 am
Post subject: Re: Hard Drives... What is now reasonably priced but just behind "cutting edge"? [Login to view extended thread Info.]

<nada DeleteThis @home.net> wrote in message
news:ts16931thco8civgv1knsrv7i6osnc8hd1@4ax.com...
> Hey all!
>
> I presently have 2 SATA HD's of 300 Gigs and 2 IDE HD's of 300 &
> 200-something Gig - and i can't tell the difference between the sppeds
> of each. All are typical CompUSA/Best Buy WD Caviar or Maxtor units
> and are 7200 with 4 or 8 meg buffers.
>
> I'm gonna upgrade and spend a little extra this time. I don't want
> the newest-high end (especially in price) HD's but I'd like what is
> now reasonable in price and better than the advertised units in the
> paper. What do I need to look for? Newegg has a WD Raptor that's
> 10,000 RPM 16MB Cache that's Serial ATA-150 for $200. 200 bones is
> fine but it's only 150 Gigs! Yikes!!! I NEED capacity.

What is your goal for the upgrade? Do you want capacity, speed, silence,
power reduction?

If capacity, then you can get SATA 750GB drives now. If you want speed, then
you found it with the raptors. If you want silence, then there are a few
options - Samsung Spinpoint is the big name, but the new WD5000AAKS I just
bought is nearly silent (and 500GB). If you want budget, then stick around
the 300GB mark, but you won't end up with more space than you have now
(assuming you are replacing).
 >> Stay informed about: Hard Drives... What is now reasonably priced but just behi.. 
Back to top
Login to vote
John Weiss

External


Since: May 04, 2006
Posts: 63



(Msg. 5) Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2007 11:37 am
Post subject: Re: Hard Drives... What is now reasonably priced but just behind "cutting edge"? [Login to view extended thread Info.]

<nada DeleteThis @home.net> wrote...
> What do I need to look for? Newegg has a WD Raptor that's
> 10,000 RPM 16MB Cache that's Serial ATA-150 for $200. 200 bones is
> fine but it's only 150 Gigs! Yikes!!! I NEED capacity.
>
> Any suggestions on fairly new tech and speed without getting soaked
> for being the first one on your block to get the cutting edge stuff?

I'd look at the WD Caviar SE16 series and the Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 series.
They both have perpendicular recording technology in the large capacity HDs,
that gives higher data density and better performance.
 >> Stay informed about: Hard Drives... What is now reasonably priced but just behi.. 
Back to top
Login to vote
Ed Medlin

External


Since: Sep 28, 2004
Posts: 398



(Msg. 6) Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2007 4:13 pm
Post subject: Re: Hard Drives... What is now reasonably priced but just behind "cutting edge"? [Login to view extended thread Info.]

"GT" <ContactGT_remove_ RemoveThis @hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:00e7ff73$0$15316$c3e8da3@news.astraweb.com...
> <nada RemoveThis @home.net> wrote in message
> news:ts16931thco8civgv1knsrv7i6osnc8hd1@4ax.com...
>> Hey all!
>>
>> I presently have 2 SATA HD's of 300 Gigs and 2 IDE HD's of 300 &
>> 200-something Gig - and i can't tell the difference between the
>> sppeds
>> of each. All are typical CompUSA/Best Buy WD Caviar or Maxtor units
>> and are 7200 with 4 or 8 meg buffers.
>>
>> I'm gonna upgrade and spend a little extra this time. I don't want
>> the newest-high end (especially in price) HD's but I'd like what is
>> now reasonable in price and better than the advertised units in the
>> paper. What do I need to look for? Newegg has a WD Raptor that's
>> 10,000 RPM 16MB Cache that's Serial ATA-150 for $200. 200 bones is
>> fine but it's only 150 Gigs! Yikes!!! I NEED capacity.
>
> What is your goal for the upgrade? Do you want capacity, speed,
> silence, power reduction?
>
> If capacity, then you can get SATA 750GB drives now. If you want
> speed, then you found it with the raptors. If you want silence, then
> there are a few options - Samsung Spinpoint is the big name, but the
> new WD5000AAKS I just bought is nearly silent (and 500GB). If you want
> budget, then stick around the 300GB mark, but you won't end up with
> more space than you have now (assuming you are replacing).
I have to agree on the WD5000AAKs. I just bought four of them for two
Raid0 arrays for A/V work and for price/performance they are very good.
Working with large files between the two arrays is noticeably faster
than any two drive combo with the possible exception of the Raptors
which would be cost prohibitive for 2tb. The large capacity allows me to
keep projects on the drives (I have everything on CD/DVD too) for easy
access if I need additional copies. Keeping critical data on Raid0
arrays is definately not reccomended. The drives are also very quiet.

Ed
>
 >> Stay informed about: Hard Drives... What is now reasonably priced but just behi.. 
Back to top
Login to vote
GT

External


Since: Jul 13, 2005
Posts: 310



(Msg. 7) Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2007 6:58 pm
Post subject: Re: Hard Drives... What is now reasonably priced but just behind "cutting edge"? [Login to view extended thread Info.]

"John Weiss" <jrweiss98155nospamatnospamcomcastdotnospamnet> wrote in
message news:q_KdnQJ-6bcgTw7bnZ2dnUVZ_tKjnZ2d@comcast.com...
> <nada.TakeThisOut@home.net> wrote...
>> What do I need to look for? Newegg has a WD Raptor that's
>> 10,000 RPM 16MB Cache that's Serial ATA-150 for $200. 200 bones is
>> fine but it's only 150 Gigs! Yikes!!! I NEED capacity.
>>
>> Any suggestions on fairly new tech and speed without getting soaked
>> for being the first one on your block to get the cutting edge stuff?
>
> I'd look at the WD Caviar SE16 series and the Seagate Barracuda 7200.10
> series. They both have perpendicular recording technology in the large
> capacity HDs, that gives higher data density and better performance.

I don't believe my new WD5000AAKS (SE 16) has perpendicular recording,
although I may be wrong. I think only the seagates have that at the mo.

Doesn't really matter!
 >> Stay informed about: Hard Drives... What is now reasonably priced but just behi.. 
Back to top
Login to vote
jaster1

External


Since: Apr 08, 2004
Posts: 204



(Msg. 8) Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2007 7:56 pm
Post subject: Re: Hard Drives... What is now reasonably priced but just behind [Login to view extended thread Info.]

On Mon, 09 Jul 2007 21:31:43 -0700, nada thoughfully wrote:

> Hey all!
>
> I presently have 2 SATA HD's of 300 Gigs and 2 IDE HD's of 300 &
> 200-something Gig - and i can't tell the difference between the sppeds
> of each. All are typical CompUSA/Best Buy WD Caviar or Maxtor units and
> are 7200 with 4 or 8 meg buffers.
>
> I'm gonna upgrade and spend a little extra this time. I don't want the
> newest-high end (especially in price) HD's but I'd like what is now
> reasonable in price and better than the advertised units in the paper.
> What do I need to look for? Newegg has a WD Raptor that's 10,000 RPM
> 16MB Cache that's Serial ATA-150 for $200. 200 bones is fine but it's
> only 150 Gigs! Yikes!!! I NEED capacity.
>
> Any suggestions on fairly new tech and speed without getting soaked for
> being the first one on your block to get the cutting edge stuff?
>
> Thanks!!!!! And any "education" on HD's would be appreciated!
>
> Thanks for your help!!!!

Maybe performance depends on lots of things but the simple answer is SATA-
II, 500-750Gig @ $100-200USD and single drive USB enclosures for $20-40
each current drive, or USB/eSATA HD server case) for all current drives.
If you have wireless and use a server you could put the server in the
basement or garage. Check out Network Attached Servers.
 >> Stay informed about: Hard Drives... What is now reasonably priced but just behi.. 
Back to top
Login to vote
Display posts from previous:   
Related Topics:
merge two hard drives using partition magic 8? - I am using Windows XP. Have computer with two hard drives installed. Primary drive is 250 gig and secondary drive is only 30 gig. There is more than 30 gig of un used space on the primary drive. Is it possible using Partition Magic 8, or perhaps....

Mildly O/T. Hard drive power down - Is there a software way to force a drive to power down? XP powers down drives after x amount of time (Control Panel -> Power Options). I have mine set to 20 minutes. I have 1 internal hard disk where I store all my admin files (patches, software..

Testing CPU & Mainboard - I have a few non-functioning mobo/cpu pairs. Question is which component of each pair (mobo-cpu) is defective? I assume a mobo will not function without a cpu, hence can I assume a POST diags card is no good without a known good CPU? If so this reduces u...

860416 - boot problem - hi i've an Albatron PX865PE Pro (v2.0) with the following configuration: CPU: intel P4 2.8 HT Enabled RAM: 3x256MB HDD: 2x; 100, 200 BIOS version: v1.24 VGA: nVidia GeForce FX 5200 the problem: sometimes when i power my computer on, it begins making a....

Motherboard problem? - Over the last several months my computer has become less and less dependable. With constant crashes for no reason (the computer just reboots) I thought there may have been something up with Windows. So I took to formatting the drive and re-installin...
   Hardware Problem Solving Community! (Home) -> Hardware General All times are: Pacific Time (US & Canada) (change)
Page 1 of 1

 
You can post new topics in this forum
You can reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum



[ Contact us | Terms of Service/Privacy Policy ]